Real and Imaginary Stories: Robinson Crusoe and the Serious Reflections
Jeffrey Hopes, Université du Maine
Volume 8, no. 3, April 1996
©McMaster University, 2015. All articles published on the Eighteenth-Century Fiction website are protected by copyright held by Eighteenth-Century Fiction, a journal published by the Faculty of Humanities at McMaster University.
ABSTRACT
Defoe’s Serious Refections during the Life and Surprising Adventures of Robinson Crusoe (1720) has enjoyed none of the universal popular success of the first part of the Crusoe trilogy. Walter Scott considered that it contained “few observations that might not have been made by any shop-keeper living at Charing Cross,” and it is only the search by modern critics for clues to Defoe’s intent in writing Robinson Crusoe that has rescued the text from total neglect. The attention that a relatively small number of critics have given to the Serious Refections has yielded some fascinating clues as to the way in which Defoe viewed his fictional craft. The most complete attempt to define Defoe’s approach to fiction from his own writings remains Maximillian Novak’s; but, as Robert Merrett has pointed out, Defoe’s critical views are so heavily subject to their rhetorical and didactic purpose that contradictions and inconsistencies make it almost impossible to weld them into a coherent theory. Within the rhetorical and didactic parameters of the Serious Reflections, however, we can see Defoe, if not defining a theory, at least grappling with the moral and epistemological issues raised by his own creation. It is of crucial importance that Defoe addressed these problems after rather than before writing the Crusoe narrative. The light thrown on Robinson Crusoe depends on the status we accord the Serious Reflections; we need to understand what Defoe was attempting to do there if we are to explore its relationship and relevance to the narrative of Crusoe’s adventures.
Other ECF articles on the topic of “Daniel Defoe” include:
“A Life of Continu’d Variety”: Crime, Readers, and the Structure of Defoe’s Moll Flanders
by KATE LOVEMAN (ECF 26.1, Fall 2013)
Real Robinson Crusoe
by MICHAEL GAVIN (ECF 25.2, Winter 2012-13)
“Zealous for Their Own Way of Worship”: Defoe, Monarchy, and Religious Toleration during the War of the Quadruple Alliance
by MORGAN STRAWN (ECF 25.2, Winter 2012-13)
©McMaster University, 2015. This copyright covers the exclusive rights to reproduce and distribute the article, including in electronic forms, reprints, translations, photographic reproductions, or similar. While reading for personal use is encouraged, Eighteenth-Century Fiction articles may not be reproduced, broadcast, published, or re-disseminated without the prior written permission of Eighteenth-Century Fiction at McMaster University. Republication, systematic reproduction, posting in electronic form, such as on a web site or in a searchable database, or other uses of this material is not allowed. The copyright in this website includes without limitation the text, computer code, artwork, photographs, images, music, audio, video, and audio-visual material on this website and is owned by McMaster University. ©McMaster University 2015.